Alicia cheated on Carl Grissom with his enforcer, Jack Napier. After Grissom learned that Jack had been seeing Alicia behind his back, he sent his right hand man on a mission that had been set up to have him killed by Lt. Max Eckhardt. Napier survived, but fell in a vat of chemicals that drastically mutated his cell structure, and freed him to become as monsterous as he desired.
After Jack Napier had reinvented himself as Joker, he scarred Alicia's face with sulphuric acid, and made her wear a porcelain mask. She then began assisting him in his deeds as the Joker, such as the vandalism of the museum. Days later, Joker presented the mask to photojournalist Vicki Vale, and informed her that Alicia threw herself out a window.
- Carl Grissom - She was his Mistress.
- Jack Napier/The Joker - He was her secret lover. She became his mistress after Grissom's death.